top of page

Stop Fixing What Was Never Broken

Writer: Tara Beiser
Tara Beiser
3 minutes ago
4 min read

What many people say ‘growth means eliminating weakness’. Learn from your mistakes and move past them. Smooth out the rough edges. Treat kindness as a nice personality trait, not a strategy. Here's the spin three speakers at TEDx Southlake helped me to ‘Unlearn’. The mistake, the trait you've been trying to sand down, the instinct to be kind, none of them need fixing. They need redirecting. That's a very different job, and it's the one most leaders skip.


I have recapped a couple of the sessions in previous posts and I wanted to reflect on a few that that align on the ‘Unlearn’ that argued the same point from completely different directions, which is usually how I know an idea is actually true and not just appealing.


The story you tell about your mistake is the real mistake.


Napoleon Rumteen recapped that he has spent three decades studying how people learn and adapt, and his talk, "Turn Yesterday's Mistakes Into Instructions for Tomorrow," opened with a distinction I haven't stopped turning over: your past experiences are real, but the meaning you assigned them might not be. We don't actually carry our failures forward. We carry the story we told ourselves about them, and that story was usually written in the worst five minutes after it happened, by the least objective version of us available.


I see this constantly in marketing teams. A campaign underperforms, and the lesson someone quietly writes for themselves isn't "the timing was wrong" or "we tested the wrong channel." It's "I'm not good at reading this market" or "I shouldn't take risks like that again." That second kind of lesson doesn't teach you anything, it just puts a smaller fence around what you're willing to try next. Rumteen's reframe is that the instruction and the interpretation are two different things, and most of us never go back to check whether the interpretation was ever true in the first place.


Kindness is a rep, not a trait.


Marleece Estella, MD, made a case I didn't expect to find as practical as I did. Her talk on the social impact of kindness argued that kindness isn't a virtue or a personality trait, it's a trainable behavior, the same way strength or endurance is. She calls the practice "Kindnesscise": intentionally exercising kindness toward yourself, the people around you, and the wider world, on a schedule, not just when you happen to feel generous.

 

The story behind the name is the part that stuck with me. On what she described as a genuinely terrible day, one small act of kindness changed how she experienced everything that followed, not because the day itself improved, but because it gave her a different lens to run the rest of it through. So she turned that into a repeatable exercise instead of a lucky accident.

 

Most leadership conversations treat kindness as culture — something you hope is present, not something you build. Estella's framing flips that. If kindness is trainable, it belongs in the same category as any other discipline a team practices on purpose: it compounds, it has reps, and you can get better at it. That's a very different standard than "be nice," and it's one I think more of us should be setting for our own teams.

 

The flaw might be the whole point.

 

Harrison Carhart's talk, "What If It Doesn't Need Fixing?", was the one that hit hardest, because it's the question I suspect most people — myself included — spend the least time actually asking. We all carry at least one thing about ourselves we've decided is a problem. Carhart's challenge: what if it isn't? What if the trait you've spent years trying to file down is actually the tool that gets you to your biggest goals, used on purpose instead of apologized for?

 

I've watched this play out in my own career more than once. The instinct to over-prepare, which I used to think of as anxiety I needed to manage, is the same instinct that's made me good in a room when a deal is falling apart. The bluntness I was coached to soften early on is the same quality that gets a stalled executive conversation back on track faster than a diplomatic version ever would. I didn't fix either of those things. I just stopped treating them as defects and started treating them as tools I already owned.

 

Now when I put these three together and you get a single, uncomfortable idea: a lot of what we're taught to eliminate, the failure, the soft skill, the flaw, was never actually the obstacle. The obstacle was the story we attached to it. Rumteen says rewrite the interpretation. Estella says kindness isn't innate, it's trained. Carhart says the flaw might be the feature. Different language, same instruction: stop trying to delete parts of yourself and your team, and start asking what each part is actually for.

 

Here's a version you can run this week. Pick one thing — a mistake you still tell a story about, a trait you've been quietly apologizing for, or a habit you've written off as just "not very strategic" of you. Don't fix it. Ask what it's useful for instead, and where you've been under-using it on purpose because you were taught it was a weakness.

 

Most of what you've been trying to fix was never broken. It was just unassigned.

 
 
 

Comments


Connect and Engage!

Select Participation / Interest

For other inquiries please contact: tara@marketingleadershiplab.com

​

© Copyright Marketing Leadership Lab 2024 – All rights reserved.

​

bottom of page